The Federal Reserve is expected to lower rates Wednesday, but the central bank's signaling and its internal fissures over inflation and jobs will be the real story for markets.
 |
| "Hawkish Cut" on the Horizon: Fed Poised for Third Straight Rate Cut Amid Deep Policy Divide |
The Fed's "Hawkish Cut": A Move Shrouded in Uncertainty
All signs point to the Federal Reserve lowering its benchmark interest rate Wednesday afternoon, a move that would mark the third consecutive cut this year and bring borrowing costs to their lowest level since 2022. But for Wall Street and Main Street alike, the central bank's decision is no longer the headline. The real drama lies in the fierce internal debate raging behind the scenes and the critical signals the Fed will send about whether this is the last cut for the foreseeable future.
The widely expected quarter-percentage point reduction would bring the federal funds rate to a target range of 3.5% to 3.75%. Traders are betting heavily on the move, with the CME FedWatch Tool showing an approximately 90% probability. However, this decision comes at one of the most fraught and divided moments for the central bank in recent memory, as policymakers grapple with a dual mandate that is pulling them in opposite directions.
The Fed's Impossible Choice: Jobs vs. Prices
The Fed is legally tasked with achieving maximum employment and stable prices. In 2025, these two goals have become increasingly difficult to balance. On one side, the labor market shows clear signs of cooling. Job gains have slowed, and the unemployment rate, while still low by historical standards, has edged up to 4.4%. Worker compensation growth has also hit a four-year low.
On the other side, inflation remains stubbornly above the Fed's 2% target. The central bank's preferred gauge showed prices rising 2.8% from a year earlier in September. Complicating matters, small business owners reported raising selling prices in November at the fastest monthly pace since early 2023, suggesting inflationary pressures are still bubbling.
“There is no risk-free path for policy as we navigate this tension between our employment and inflation goals,” Fed Chair Jerome Powell conceded in October.
This tension has split the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) into opposing camps. One group favors cutting rates to head off further weakness in the job market, while another believes further easing risks aggravating inflation and wants to pause. This division was on full display at the October meeting, where one official dissented in favor of a larger half-point cut, while another voted for no cut at all.
What to Watch: The "Hawkish Cut" and the "Dot Plot"
Given this split, economists believe the Fed will engineer what markets call a "hawkish cut". This means the central bank will lower rates but accompany the move with a strong message that the door to further reductions is now mostly closed.
“The likeliest outcome is a kind of hawkish cut where they cut, but the statement and the press conference suggest that they may be done cutting for now,” said Bill English, the Fed’s former director of monetary affairs.
Investors will scrutinize every word of the Fed's 2:00 p.m. ET policy statement and Powell's 2:30 p.m. ET press conference for this hawkish tone. The key will be any change in language regarding the "extent and timing of additional adjustments," which is expected to signal that "the bar for any further cuts will be somewhat higher".
Equally important will be the updated "dot plot," the chart that anonymously plots each Fed official's interest rate projections. The September plot showed officials forecasting just one more rate cut in all of 2026. Any shift in this outlook will heavily influence market expectations. Analysts also anticipate seeing multiple "soft dissents" within the dot plot, visually underscoring the committee's lack of consensus.
The Political and Practical Overhang
Two major uncertainties loom over the entire proceeding. First, a lack of critical economic data due to the recent government shutdown has left policymakers "flying blind". Key reports on jobs and inflation from October and November have been delayed, making it harder to gauge the true health of the economy.
Second, leadership transition is adding to the instability. Chair Powell's term expires in May 2026, and President Trump has indicated he will name a successor months earlier than usual. Trump has been a vocal critic of the Fed, demanding lower rates and stating that a commitment to cut "immediately" would be a "litmus test" for his nominee. This creates the unprecedented scenario of a "shadow Fed chair" influencing markets while Powell is still in charge.
What This Means for You
For American consumers, the cumulative effect of three rate cuts could eventually translate into some relief, though the changes will be gradual.
Borrowers: Rates on credit cards, home equity lines of credit, and auto loans are likely to edge lower. However, don't expect mortgage rates to plummet; they are influenced by long-term bond markets, which have been rising on inflation concerns.
Savers: The era of high-yield savings accounts offering robust returns is likely winding down. Interest paid on savings and checking accounts, already low, may drift even lower.
Investors: The stock market has largely priced in today's expected cut. The real market mover will be the Fed's guidance for 2026. A definitively hawkish message could dampen optimism, while any hint of more cuts ahead could provide a boost.
The Bottom Line
Wednesday's decision is less about a single rate cut and more about the Fed navigating a policy crossroads. With the economy sending mixed signals, inflation still present, and political winds shifting, the central bank is attempting to thread an incredibly fine needle. Its success will depend not just on the action it takes today, but on the clarity and conviction of the message it sends about tomorrow.
Federal Reserve rate cut, FOMC meeting December 2025, hawkish cut, Jerome Powell, inflation vs employment, dot plot, mortgage rates, Fed dissent, monetary policy 2026